Calling all participants of the DPT Summer League...
Tired of Chandler writing "Me and Geoff discussed ___ and decided ___ ...."?
Who "oficially" made them league commishioners?
Every week when I play and I have an objection (cough being forced to participate in long drive competition) I get reminded from Chandler that "those all the rules Geoff and I came up with"
So I decided to finally read these "league rules" this morning but wa suprised to find NO link promimently displaying them. I went through the archives and found a May 19th Blog Posting introducing the league and decribing the DPT Point system as well as a Kickoff Open Posting mentioning greenies, and the long drive for that week's tournament.
Well as you can read from an earlier post, I was harassed once again at the conclusion of the tournament by none other than Geoff and Chandler. When we calculated the net scores we found Geoff and I were tied for third so it was first decided to split the 150 DPT points. This did not sit well with Geoff so after being relentlesly harassed about a OB score decision (that was agreed upon when that hole concluded) I succombed to peer pressure and went and replayed the fifth hole 3 hours after last playing it.
The re-play is recorded for everyone's enjoyment to point and laugh at Gorecki. And now my entire round and score was adjusted and I left in 4th place accumulated no DPT League Points.
So after replaying that day's events I decided to see what "the DPT League Rules" say about a tie. Gasp nothing listed! I then researched the USGA rules and found the following:
"Sudden death is not recommended by the USGA in such cases. It's felt that
playing hole-by-hole shouldn't decide a tie in stroke play. Instead, a playoff
over 18 holes is the favored format. If that's not feasible, then a nine-, six-,
or three-hole in that order) playoff is preferable."
Why wasn't this approach ever mentioned or suggested? WHy do we feel my entire round and tie-break should go back to replaying a hole that (at the time) we agreed to a score I should record only to have it retracted?
So given I see no "official" election making Geoff and Chandler league commishioners and continuing to enforce rules that arent even properly listed. I ask for the opinion of the rest of league. Should the round between Geoff and I conclude the way it originally did (tie and split the points)? Should we have replayed my 4th shot on hole 5 thus deciding the entire round? Should we have agreed to a certain number of holes playoff?
I ask for YOU the league participants to vote. You have a voice! You too can put a stop to this dictatorship of a league. Coup d'etat!
Haha I was waiting for this.
ReplyDelete1) We made ourselves in charge. You know... the guys that came up with the idea for the league, how to manage it and how to track everything.
2) The May 19th blog post that you referenced clearly says:
"Every tournament will have a $5 entry fee ($10 for Majors). Payouts will depend on how many people are entered. Each group will also gamble $1 on a designated long drive hole, and $1 on each of the par 3s. Eagles get an extra dollar from every competitor. Any score 10+ over par (net) owes the group a pitcher of beer after the round."
Basically... you just start complaining before you read things. Last I checked "every tournament" is not specific to the Kickoff Open
3) You weren't pressured. We sweetened the deal with free money until your confidence got the best of you. And it was awesome.
4) Ties are also clearly listed in the blog post you linked to.
5) This is a dictatorship. Hows our dic-tate?
6) Most courses won't let us have playoff holes. Even first place will be split (as clearly stated in the rules).
7) Start using that 61 degree club and you'll score better.
I'm not reading any of this
ReplyDeleteYou didn't tie. You just made up some rules and winged it.
ReplyDeleteIf you want to get technical.... Per USGA
PENALTY FOR BREACH OF RULE 6-6b: Disqualification.
• d. Wrong Score for Hole The competitor is responsible for the correctness of the score recorded for each hole on his score card. If he returns a score for any hole lower than actually taken, he is disqualified. If he returns a score for any hole higher than actually taken, the score as returned stands.
So technically you should have been disqualified.
Also what is so hard about reading the Rules/Schedule/Betting? Everything is written out in a pretty clear and concise manner.
ReplyDeleteP.S. Gorecki, you aren't the only one who doesn't read the blog.
Great rant Gorecki... But, how is it everyone knows the league rules except you? We get to decide because we took the initiative and decided to make golf more fun.
ReplyDeleteRules is rules.
That is a very concise point Bito. Techincally by USGA rules Gorecki would have DQ'd. Not replaying his shot from the fairway to begin with would have given him a different score.
ReplyDeleteThe group agreed with my decision to drop the ball there and take a penalty stroke for reason's on "Pace of Play" as we were a 5some and didn't want to continue to hold up groups playing behind us.
ReplyDeleteSo you can't really quote USGA rules as the exception was made here.
And can't we make the same "disqualification argument" when we pick up our balls after a double par is reached? I'm sure this would constitute a disqualification according to USGA rules as well as that player who picked up his ball did not finish.
The group didn't agree with you. We were just tired of making the one guy behind us wait while you got all hot and bothered.
ReplyDeleteYou had four chances at the hole.
1) Recorded a six by playing your OB shot as a lateral hazard (blatantly cheating).
2) Duffed your first attempt at a re-play, picked up and conceded the hole for an 8.
3) Hit your second attempt at a re-play over the cart path and OB... essentially earning you an 8.
4) Played your second OB shot as "in bounds" and still recorded an 8 thanks to some horrible putting.
After all that, we gave you a 7 because our Totalitarian league has some random acts of sympathy.
And the rules link is back up at the top of the blog. Enjoy reading all that, Pace of Play.
ReplyDeleteWhat group agreed with you? We thought you were taking a two stroke penalty.
ReplyDeleteNo thats when I said I'd go replay it and I'm taking a one stroke penalty cause I'm doing this for "pace of play". I even said if I get assessed a two stroke, then I'll go re hit from the mound. Thats when Chandler said "fine we will give u the 6, get in the cart and let's go"
ReplyDeleteI'm pretty sure I said:
ReplyDelete"Just finish up and we'll figure it out later."
Then as we walked to the next tee you claimed you should only have a 6. But clearly, as you showed in that video... you deserved an 8.