We start back up in 11 days! I'm behind in rolling over the schedule, but I'll get on that ASAP now that I'm back in town.
Voting on new members will start today and end on Sunday. Check your emails.
Also be sure to get your registration for next season updated. Dave, Greg, Ben and Danny have yet to do so. If you see one of those people, tell them to get on it.
-------------------------
The Board asked me to post a reminder on how to play hazards (red vs. yellow). You can refresh yourself with this very short, and quite excellent, write-up I did last year. Please read the first part of it again.
We only consider policy and rules changes once a year, but one the Board discussed is the Double Par Tampa rule, of setting double-par as a max score on each hole. The discussion centered around: "Is DP the best max? Should we keep it? If we changed it what would be better?"
Wide range of opinions: leave it alone... no maximum score... +4 max.... max of 10 regardless of par.... etc.
Again, the purpose of the Board is to discuss and consider all aspects of league rules, even if there isn't any pressing problem with current policy. But they are elected by you, so give it some thought and tell your representatives your opinion on the matter. If you even have an opinion.
More to come about the new season soon!
I think pace of play would be much worse if we had no max. I think we should stick with double par.
ReplyDeleteI’m with Big Dick. Nice hole in one btw!!
ReplyDeleteHis ace was legit. Solid strike. Dead on line. Took forever to trickle in. Maybe one day we will see one in league play.
ReplyDeleteNo max isn't the only option. +4 +5, and 10 max were also discussed. I've always been partial to +4, but I'm starting to think +5 would be better. I don't think par 3's are weighted evenly enough to the rest at +3 max.
ReplyDeleteThe main question that was asked is: "Are higher handicaps unfairly helped by a +3 max on par 3s?"
ReplyDeleteI'm still planning on doing some analysis on this during the next season. Obviously any time you increase a max, you run the risk of increasing pace of play. Unless you're Tall Mike, who already grinds over putts after the max for "practice."
Interestingly enough, the proposed 2020 handicap changes by the USGA allows us to set a max score per hole, which we already do without their blessing.
I like 10 as the max. That’s what I’ve always played.
ReplyDeletePractice?! We talking about practice?
ReplyDeleteWhen we do some more analysis of this I doubt we will find too many winners of events that had more than 1 or 2 max double pars during the round but I bet we could find a ton of times where someone took 2nd/3rd/4th over someone by a stroke or two with a handful of 6s and 8s on their card and I think that’s unfair. My vote would be to either do away with max scoring all together or set a high one, like 10.
ReplyDeleteTell me if anyone thinks this is fair.
Par 3 over water. Player A dumps first one in the water, re-tee, dumps the next one in the water. Re-tees again and has a guaranteed 6 no matter what he does with the next ball unless he makes a hole in one for 5, like ol’ big Richard Broom. Player B dumps first one in the water, re-tees, puts it on the green and makes a 3-putt 6. Do those two people deserve the same score? If I’m player B and I lose out on some points to player A by a stroke or two, I’m rightfully pissed.
Pace of play problems are more related to the clowns that don’t know how to manage carts, aren’t ready to play when it’s their turn, and have long pre-shot routines only to inevitably top the ball.
I think +5 is still the best. It punishes every hole equally and severely. I think 7 strokes is too much to penalize on one hole.
ReplyDeleteIt’s not a 7 stroke penalty. You sucked at golf on 10 straight swings. +/- a few swings for hazards.
ReplyDeleteMay be a bit harder to calculate, but what about something like net double par max?
ReplyDeleteThat would require every player to know exactly how many strokes they were getting on which holes. The higher your handicap, the less likely you would know that. Coming off a gross 9, there is zero chance you're going to look at the next hole's handicap and go: "ok cool, I can make only an 8 here." Also... with said high handicapper... they're already slow enough as it is.
ReplyDeleteThe USGA is allegedly moving to some shit like this in 2020, getting rid of the current ESC max for handicap recording. It'll be a complete mess, as someone who gets 26 strokes will NOT take the time to see which of the 8 holes they get two strokes on went over their allowed net max. People can't handle simple tasks in golf.
The last paragraph in Faz's comment is 100% true about pace of play.
Pace of play will never get fixed IMO. You will never convince Tall Mike that one practice swing is enough or Reid that his ball is 30 yards in the lake or Gorecki that the clean and jerk is simply not an effective putting strategy. I also don't think that two extra strokes on par 3s or one on 4s is going to slow things down much more. Hit provisionsals look for your 2 minutes and get on with it.
ReplyDeleteI like quad max personally. On a par 72 course if you maxed every hole your score would be the same under double par or quad max. Not getting off the tee on a par 3 should be more painful than just 3 strokes. My concern is that par fives tend to be the holes we high handicappers get 2 strokes on effectively making those max double net which seems a little unfair, but then again they are also the holes the low guys get a stroke on.
Disclosure:
My intent is not to piss anyone off with the above callouts everyone has their slow tendencies and those were the first 3 I came up with. If someone could convince faz to just take a max when he gets to chipping distance in 2 that would speed things up. Keep Gary from driving the cart faster. Keep Katie from drinking at pebble creek alot faster. Talk to Rease about the fact you don't have to hit 14 drivers to call it a golf game faster. Teach everyone to grab a club and tee off when you get to the tee box, assuming you're not playing behind the 4some of death at countryside (Gary, Reid, Dave and Moostie), faster.
I'm always talked too about not using driver on every hole. BD and Web love educating me. I will never lay up.
ReplyDeleteJohn uses 0 drivers per round...
ReplyDeleteSo were net net than.
ReplyDeleteI like dubs suggestions of +5, I also like John’s social shaming but even when we have a little Italy night these rarely work!
ReplyDeleteGorecki hasn’t hit anyone in the face with a ball or lied about his score since Little Italy. So maybe it DID help??
ReplyDeleteHe probably has tried to get a free checked bag on an airplane though...
ReplyDeleteDrive slower??? I'm confused...I agree with Faz.
ReplyDelete