Friday, July 13, 2018

Picking for Pitchers Review

In the name of #content, BGR has decided to review the wildly popular Picking for Pitchers contest brought to you by the Boozer's Golf Review. We've used our multitude of bachelors and graduate degrees to bring you the most scientific analysis of the picks available. Basically, our statistics are the best statistics. We had the Russians hack Faz Stats, so we know that ours our literally the greatest stats in the world. You'll all be thanking us profusely for having these amazing stats. Make Stats Great Again! Very cool, Kanye!

We started by laying out the picks and seeing what they looked like. We even put Danny's picks in the analysis even though they didn't count. Let this be a lesson to those lurkers out there, especially those married to league statisticians, that picks are always appreciated even if you aren't competing for the pitchers. Green means the pick was correct, and red means incorrect. Then we checked to see how the league fared as a whole on the picks and also how confident the league generally was in each matchup. Here are the results.


Analysis and commentary are below...


  • Everyone thinks really poorly of Gorecki. We aren't sure if there's a stigma about picking him or if it was just his putrid play of late, but everyone was wrong on that one.
  • Not only was everyone wrong, the league in general was extraordinarily confident. In fact, of a possible 336 confidence points, the league lost 22% on that pick alone. Very confident in a bad pick.
  • Not the BGR, though. The BGR knew this would be a close battle, hence the rankings led us to only put one confidence point at risk for this pick. Perhaps Gorecki is a better Booze golfer than the current power rankings suggest? Or perhaps the bears were hibernating due to cart path only golf?
  • The BGR was very wrong about Gary, though. Perhaps we need to give him more old man Boozer credibility.
  • BGR co-founder J.W. was the only other league favorite to not win other than Katie. We at the BGR attribute this to his backing out of plans to go to the bar with friends the night before and not living up to his full Boozer capabilities. Lesson learned, we hope.
  • Other big winners for the league were Brendan over Ho, Faz, and Gary. 
  • Everyone seemed to be very confident in the Gary v John matchup, but half the league picked incorrectly as John was the third biggest loser of points after Katie and J.W.
  • The league is pretty good at picking our 4th most confident competitor, getting 83% of those right. We're very bad at picking our most and least confident competitors getting only 25% of each of those right.
  • Big John had the most unique pick as the only one to select a halve of a match, and he ended up being right to win 2 points. Still not nearly enough to keep him from doing what he does best: buying booze for his fellow league members.
We also discovered an error in record keeping. This is what the BGR gets for farming any duties out to non-top-10 Boozers. Chandler didn't check the picks thoroughly enough and didn't record Ho's terrible picks. These are truly the worst picks we've ever seen. It can't be overstated how bad these picks were. SAD! Anyway, Ho owes Chandler a pitcher, but really he just owes the league a pitcher because Chandler deserved to buy one due to his shoddy record keeping.

The BGR is anxiously awaiting all of the pitchers that will be purchased at Carrollwood Country Club on Sunday. Hopefully they've stocked up on kegs of domestic lagers.

7 comments:

  1. This underrated Boozer "missed" Ho's picks, because he published them exactly 9 minutes before the first group's published tee time... and considering we went out early... whist we were all standing on the first tee watching Gorecki top his drive to the ladies teebox (en-route to a sketchy par save).

    They are some of the worst picks I've ever seen. You could throw darts at picks and still get more than one correct.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I was wondering how the picks shook out. Nice write up!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Faz, who's the best Match player in the League?

    ReplyDelete
  4. Chandler already tracks historical match play performance. It’s on the stats tab. http://dptgolf.blogspot.com/p/career.html?m=1

    ReplyDelete
  5. I feel like Gary was trying to pull an evil queen thing there. Mirror, mirror on the wall, who’s the greatest match player of them all? Watch out Robbie. Gary is probably going to try and give you a poison Apple tomorrow.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Pitcher was purchased. I agree, my picks were terrible

    ReplyDelete