Thursday, October 21, 2021

Buchert's Off-Season Thoughts - 2021 Edition

We have a Board meeting next week. Below was sent in by Buchert, for review and discussion:

-------------------------------------

Random Off Season Ideas – Which will all be rejected, but I’m going to put them forward anyway to help Dear Leader with #content.

- Relegation: I was late to the party and just started watching Ted Lasso. First of all, it is an
amazing show and I highly recommend checking it out. For those of you that are unfamiliar with
the term Relegation, the British Football (soccer) Leagues have a system where the bottom
teams are demoted to the lower league and the best teams from the lower leagues can be
promoted to a higher league. With our league basically maxed out for membership, should we
look at a Relegation system to make things interesting at the bottom of the rankings each
season? This is coming from someone that has spent A LOT of time in last place. If there are
people that are interested in joining the league but there is no room, this could be a decent way
of rotating people in. Ultimately, if you do get relegated, you would be able to get back in the
after the following season because other players would then be relegated.

- Get rid of lift, clean and place in the fairways: This rule was around before I joined the league,
so I’m not sure why it was implemented. However, it seems odd that we try to follow some of
the most complicated rules of golf and ignore the most basic: play your ball as it lies. If we’re
thinking about getting rid of gimme putts, maybe we should just go all the way and play golf in
its purest form?

- Set handicaps at the beginning of the season and make no adjustment throughout the season as
far as league events or potentially just one or two adjustments. Obviously, this would get rid of
or lessen the fact that playing well in the beginning of the season makes it harder to win at the
end of the season.

- Adjust the “good” pitcher score down to -8 or lower. So that there is no financial penalty for
shooting a good score, the person shooting the worst net score in your foursome has to buy the
pitcher.

14 comments:

  1. Do we all get to call chandler with our post ideas and have him type them up for us? I wasn't aware that was a service offered in this fine club. Don't get me wrong, I'm happy for the content but these are all bad ideas starting with the notion that Ted Lasso is a good show. Secondly, if Buchert can get the courses in our area to take better care of their fairways, then maybe we could implement playing it as it lies. I like the rule because you shouldn't be penalized in the fairway because your ball lands in what could be a literal goat track.

    ReplyDelete
  2. He actually emailed these to me. I assume his company blocks the blog. Which makes sense, as it is his actual company.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I actually have no idea how to create a new thread. I know it's probably not difficult, but I'm too lazy to learn anything new.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Geoff and I had this debate about Ted Lasso at the Rapture and his main reason for not liking it is "The plot is too warm and heartfelt". Just go back to enjoying your Squid Game streaming there Jeffe.

    And I'll use this post for proposals to the board as well as I fear my emails to the Commish are probably just routed to his spam folder....

    -Bring back the distribution of tournament winnings each week
    I miss the days of winning tournaments and receiving cash at the post bar/restaurant, but understand the inconvenience it caused for the commish to go around to each member before starting the round and collect the entry fees. And thus pre season payments were set up to alleviate that burden. But now that 95% of the members have PayPal/Venmo/Zelle/etc I'd like to propose the top finishers get their winnings transferred to them.

    -Distribute winnings at end of season
    If weekly distribution of payouts is too time consuming how bout at the end of the season? And if thats too burdensome then just those that have winnings of over $130?

    -Payouts for Top Finishers at Skins Tournament Payouts
    Not sure this has been proposed before but since the skins tournament pays out for skins and points for top place finishers, shouldn't top place finishers also receive winnings? Guess we'd have to increase club dues to accommodate this.

    -Payouts for Winner of Match Play
    Similar premise where you are currently awarded points but no cash for a win in match play.

    -Ungroomed Bunkers
    As Geoff mentioned the goat tracks we play at times don't have the budget to properly maintain their courses, and thus the sand traps are often in poor condition. So should we allow members to lift their ball and groom the area of the bunker beneath it?

    ReplyDelete
  5. Really sounds like Gorecki is hurting for money.

    Club Credit is a necessary feature to be able to have leverage over some of you.

    All your request about "additional" payouts would require "additional" pay-ins... you can't pay out Skins AND the tournament unless we pony up more money before the event. Also, you suggested this before and it was rejected.

    Payouts for Match Play is dumb... because that would literally translate to a sidebet between the two participants. You don't need the Club to handle that transaction. Bet your opponent before the match.

    As for bunkers... go read Playing Rule #9

    ReplyDelete
  6. Here's the recap (2019) where Gorecki suggested additional payout for the Skins game. Maybe John's feelings have changed?

    ReplyDelete
  7. While I agree we play out of bad bunkers, it’s called a hazard and you’re not supposed to be in them. Unlike a fairway, where you shouldn’t be penalized for a good shot.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Without request, here is my reasoning behind proposing getting ride of lift, clean and place:

    I think the notion that you should not have a bad lie in a fairway is improperly ingrained in the brains of a lot of amateur golfers. The idea that you should never have to play from a bad lie because you hit a fairway is not very different than Gorecki thinking he should never have to make a two foot putt. When broken down to their core, both thought processes rely on the belief that the rules of golf should not apply to that individual.

    Most of the courses that we play do not have the money or staff to maintain their course in the condition it was intended to be played. This includes the fairways, greens and the rough. World Woods comes to mind as a recent example. There were areas on some of the greens where you had to putt through sand. There were also areas around the greens where the grass had either completely died off or was just hanging on which created scenarios where you were trying to hit a chip shot to an elevated green without any grass under the ball.

    When you catch one of those bad breaks, you deal with it, play your ball as it lies and move on. We do not debate whether the bad break is fair based on the quality of the shot that led to the bad break. More importantly, we do not pay any attention to what the lie would have been if we were playing a nicer course. Yet, it seems like these are the two reasons why we play lift, clean and place in all fairways (1. A bad lie in the fairway is unfair because you hit a “good” shot; and 2. If the course was nicer, you would have a better lie).

    Ultimately, the rule is sheer hypocrisy. With that said, I don't think there is any way that the Board will get rid of the rule so I'm pretty sure I just wasted five minutes of my life typing this explanation.

    ReplyDelete
  9. The ironic thing is the "professionals" play Lift, Clean and Place in the fairways AND rough way more than you realize. More and more, the PGA TOUR has utilized "preemptive preferred lies" when the forecast is showing any rain.

    There's also a lot of talk about "nicer courses," as if those exist in Tampa. All the courses we play have similar conditioning, and we usually avoid the ones that have gone into complete disrepair.

    Having lush grass under the ball isn't traditional golf. The fairways at St. Andrews were concrete — in June — very much resembling Heritage Harbor. But nobody complained because it's, you know, St. Andrews.

    There was one Australian man who wished the fairways had more grass to cushion his fall, after Gorecki sniped him from 95 yards...

    ReplyDelete
  10. I would be in favor of either getting rid of lift, clean and place OR playing lift, clean and place in all areas that are not a hazard (i.e. fairway and the rough).

    I realize that the current rule provides a competitive advantage to the traditional style of play promoting hitting fairways, as opposed to bomb and gouge. Even though there is nothing in the rules of golf that says we should promote such a strategy, it seems to be favored by golf purists.

    ReplyDelete
  11. I’m not opposed to getting rid of lift clean and place in the fairway. I just don’t think it’ll happen and the policing of said rule would be a nightmare. I can’t argue with any of Brian’s points about the policy.

    ReplyDelete
  12. I would be for no gimmies and no lift clean and place. I get made fun of by other golfers when I bring them up.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Your other golf friends are totally fluffing their lies in the rough, and rolling balls out of divots in the fairway.

    They want the illusion of playing as the Honourable Company of Edinburgh Golfers intended in 1744. But they're still cheating when nobody is looking.

    ReplyDelete