Thursday, September 1, 2022

The Greatest Golfer in Club History

 

The Greatest Golfer in Club History

I plan on posting a few times on the Blog this off-season just to keep the #content train rolling since we won’t have any posts on upcoming events or recaps.  I usually have some free time in the morning before my daughter wakes up.  One of the things I do while having a cup of coffee is check the Blog for any updates or new posts.  99% of the content that we have on the Blog is from Chandler and, while I thank him for his time and dedication to the League, I also feel like the rest of us could be contributing more. 

I have written a few things over the last two weeks, but most of them have to do with me and my golf game.  I did not intentionally set out to do this, but I just didn’t play a lot of golf with most of the people in the League this past season.  I played six rounds and was matched up with Tall Mike all six times, Faz and Topor three times (I think), and Troy twice.  For a few of those rounds, we either had a threesome or had a guest playing as the fourth.  It is hard to write about someone else’s golf game when you did not get to see them play.  I would love to be able to do a breakdown of what has happened to Gary’s golf game, but I have not been fortunate enough to witness that train wreck firsthand.  I do have a write up for Tall Mike though that I hope you all will find entertaining.

However, since most of the content is going to be tied to me in some way, I wanted to kick things off with a post that has nothing to do with me and that is:

The League has been in existence for 10 years, who is the greatest golfer in League history?

To start things off, I want to clarify that I would consider the Greatest Golfer in League History and the Greatest Champion in League History two different things.  (Don’t worry, I have a separate post written to break down the Greatest Champion in League History.)  The Greatest Golfer in League History could be the same person as the Greatest Champion in League History, but that does not have to be the case.

As our League uses an imperfect system to try to level the playing field between golfers of different skill levels, the best player is not always going to be the Champion at the end of a season.  Furthermore, the best golfer at a given moment in time is not necessarily the greatest golfer in League history.  Tom Brady does not win the MVP every year, but he is considered by most to be the GOAT.  His sustained excellence has separated him from his peers.  I don’t think that we have a Tom Brady of the League; someone that has separated himself from other players in the league to such a degree that there is no longer room for a meaningful discussion.  If we did, this would be a very short post.  So here are the contenders, in no specific order, and I’m interested to see if there is a consensus as to who should be considered the Greatest Golfer in League History:

1.     Chandler Brown.  The argument for why he should be considered the greatest is rock solid.  He has the most events played, most wins, most 2nd place finishes, a scoring average of 85.6, the most Greenies, the most Long Drives, the most Sandies, and four Championships.  He is like the Kareem Abdul-Jabbar of our League.  His longevity and sustained excellence really stands out when you compare his stats to the rest of the League.  Are some of his numbers inflated due to the first few seasons of the League when we had less Members?  Sure they are.  That is the reason why there is room for debate when it comes down to Chandler or one of the guys listed below.  His win percentage is 11.7%, he averages 1.05 Greenies per round, and his Long Drive win percentage is 29.7%.  His match play record is a very respectable 16-8-4.

2.     Mike Oostenbrink.  He has the most Modern Era Championships (four), 6 Majors (just one less than Chandler), and has the most epic Championship in League history when he won the final two events of the Summer 2020 Season to steal the Cup away from Gorecki.  He has done this playing in 128 events, which is 60 less events than Chandler has played in.  However, his scoring average is 94.3, his win percentage is 10.1%, Greenies per round is 0.77, and Long Drive win percentage is 18%.  In my opinion, Tall Mike is like the Robert Horry of the League.  He has some of the most clutch performances and shots that we will remember forever, but nobody is going to say he was a better player than the greats of that era:  Jordan, Kobe, Duncan, etc.

3.      Dave Harrington.  Irish Dave has a scoring average of 83.5 and he has put up that average while playing many rounds from a harder set of tees.  Comparing Dave to Chandler and Tall Mike is not an apples to apples comparison.  Dave’s Greenies per round is 1.11, which is better than Tall Mike and Chandler’s averages, but how much “extra credit” should Dave get due to the fact that he wins those Greenies from one or two sets of tee boxes farther back then the rest of the guys in his group?  As far as Long Drive, his win percentage is 27.3% and is better than Chandler and Tall Mike.  Once again, he is doing that while giving up yardage to the rest of his group (usually).  He also has a great match play record of 15-5-2.  His win percentage is 9.4%, which is lower than Chandler and Tall Mike.  I don’t know if that can be blamed on tee boxes.  He also only has half as many wins as Chandler (11 compared to 22).  Dave is like Giannis or Michael Jordan, where the stats alone are great but somehow do not tell the whole story.

4.       Chris Melberg.  Melberg has only played in 34 events, so he has not had time to collect the same career stats as the other guys on this list.  Nonetheless, his short time in the League has already produced some numbers that put him in consideration as the greatest.  He has the lowest scoring average at 82.6.  He has the lowest gross score to par in League history when he went -6 at Southport Springs.  His match play record is excellent, 5-0-1.  He averages 1.14 Greenies per round.  His Long Drive win percentage is 20.6%.  Like Irish Dave, he has played many of his rounds from a harder tee box than everyone else in his group.  Despite his low handicap index, his win percentage is still a respectable 8.8%.  To switch up the sports as far as his comparison, I would say he’s kind of like Chargers QB Justin Herbert.  His stats from his first few seasons are comparable to the best of all time.  However, he has yet to win a Championship and just hasn’t had enough time to rack up the career statistics that some other guys have.

Some people were left off the top contenders list and here is why:

5.       Dan Rogers:  His scoring average is 85.0, but that is more than 2 shots worse than Melberg.  Dan and Melberg have very comparable stats, but Melberg’s scoring average gave him the advantage.

6.       Darren Broom.  He has the most Majors and a great win percentage (13%).  His scoring average is 94.0 though.  Tall Mike has a similar scoring average (94.3) and has double the Cups.  He got the nod over The Baron.

7.       Faz, Gary and Reid:  These three guys have all racked up an impressive amount of wins, Greenies and Long Drives.  However, they do not stack up well when compared to Chandler’s stats and their scoring averages are higher as well.

The rest of you (myself included) do not deserve a mention. 

To be honest, when I started writing this, I thought Chandler would blow everyone away.  I didn’t realize how great of a ball striker Irish Dave is until I started looking at his Greenies per round and Long Drive win percentage.  I think it’s very close between those two guys right now and if we check back in another 10 years, Melberg will probably be right there with them.

7 comments:

  1. Shit. This means there's going to be a worst golfer in league history.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Yes there is. I had a good time looking at the stats for that one.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I think you should weigh club credit here, too. Didn't realize that Dave is basically a club credit ATM, and it more or less comes straight out of my wallet. I'm taking up Ho's slack on extremely unlikely goals and setting my bar at 3 wins next season to double my current total. Check out all my runner up finishes, though. I do have a better top 2 percentage than several folks. I might need to edit your piece on worst golfer to provide some more expert analysis. Just saying.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Great write up. But I was really hoping everyone was going to get a Laker comparison after reading the first two. The Tall Mike:Robert Horry comparison is spot on!

    ReplyDelete
  5. I think a Magic Johnson comparison probably works for Dave. Widely considered the best point guard ever, but is still probably underrated overall.

    I can't think of anyone for Melberg though. Maybe a young Kobe? Everyone that watched him play could see his potential and so long as he doesn't go and get himself imprisoned for rape, he is destined to go down as one of the greatest.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I appreciate the mention, but I don’t belong on this list.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I got some good laughs reading this and look forward to more to come. It sounds like some people are already fearful. Generally the different tee boxes are 2-3 strokes, I argue that course records should have a adjusted score column. Another metric is world rankings.

    ReplyDelete